Glasgow’s Springburn, once the proud birthplace for steam locomotives sent to every corner of empire, is now notorious for “acting” as sink estate for the disposessed, Crusoe’d with a buckfastering of de-humanised ex-working classes; and more recently as rubik cubes for those expecting, and being sorely disappointed of, a better life in dear old North Blighty.
Not far from a massive Tesco (built on top of the St Rollox train factory, and probably the most multicultural shopping space in Glasgow), lie the Red road flats. Occupied in 1969, along with other “slab and point” high rise blocks (its westerly neighbours at Sighthill, across the road from Tesco, were blown up in November 2009), it became recently another icon of the scottish film industry’s middle-class infatuation with its long line of cliched tartan schemies, thistle’d druggies, hoots-mon jakies and sociopaths wearing see-you-jimmy bunnets.
As they used to say in Kelvinside, in their stanley baxter accents – ohhhh… the DEPREDATION…. hev anither wee g an t tae calm yer nerves, Maisie… noo whaur’s yon re-mastered re-issue af Trainspotting, wi’ extra slamdugging…
It would be fair to say now at this point I intensly dislike the studied-from-a-safe-distance, preferably Hyndland or Dartford, morally bankrupt sub-Loach kitchen-sinkery of films like Ratcatcher, Small Faces and recent cctv downer Red Road. Even the knuckle-dragging, Howson-shaped thuggery of tartan noir, er, “literature”, seeks a higher place than these imposed sub-hoi-polloi stereotypes of scottish people. Like bad architecture, slumxploitation films can have a lasting and damaging influence on the psyche of the decent people who are left behind to shrug off the slurs and labels that are still attached long after the directors’ star has faded. Meanwhile the egos-the-size-of-hampden (I am loving my hyphens) filmbrats from the right side of town slum it and think they’re doing serious and important homage to robert louis stevenson.
Anyway, the scottish photographer George Logan is a perfect example of good intentions made muddy by the ability to fake reality out of other people’s misery. On the surface, the quasi-allegorical nature of the images and the cartier-bresson quality moments give a feeling of delight and hope – I was completely taken in. It’s when you look more closely at where Logan is coming from (london-based, high-end advertising photography) and then, crushingly, his quite open (to his credit) admission that the figures are actors (on possibly a bluescreen set) with the tableau then comped on top of the Red road backgrounds, that things go slightly awry. That said he seems a really decent guy who is surely not naive about the social context and local compromises he’s chosen to work with here, unlike some.
Image copyright George Logan
